Uncovering Root Causes: The Power of 5W1H and 5 Whys

In business, problem-solving goes beyond surface-level fixes. To truly resolve issues, it’s essential to dig deep and uncover the root causes. Two of the most effective tools for this purpose are the 5W1H method and 5 Whys. These questioning frameworks provide structure to help individuals and organisations identify the underlying reasons behind problems and inefficiencies, leading to more sustainable solutions.

This blog explores how 5W1H and 5 Whys work, and why they are so valuable in both Lean and Six Sigma methodologies for identifying and solving problems.

5W1H: Revealing the Layers of a Problem

The 5W1H framework stands for Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How. By systematically addressing these six key questions, organisations can uncover critical information at each stage of problem analysis. This method allows you to explore different dimensions of a problem, ensuring that nothing is overlooked. Here’s how each element works:

Who?

The “Who” questions focus on the people involved in the process. Consider:

• Who is involved in the issue?
• Who should be involved in solving it?
• Who else can contribute to resolving it?
• Who is responsible for inefficiencies?

Identifying the right individuals involved in the problem helps pinpoint both responsibility and resources that can assist in the resolution.

What?

This focuses on the actions that are taking place:

• What actions are necessary to solve the problem?
• What is currently being done, and is it effective?
• What could be improved to prevent the issue?
• What contributes to waste or inefficiency in the process?

Asking “What” forces you to look at the specifics of the problem and how current efforts may or may not be addressing it.

Where?

The “Where” questions help to localise the problem:

• Where is the activity taking place?
• Where should this action ideally be happening?
• Where are inefficiencies or delays occurring?

Understanding where the problem happens is vital for effective intervention. Sometimes, simply adjusting the location of a task or process can significantly reduce waste or errors.

When?

Timing is critical in problem-solving. Consider:

• When should actions occur?
• When does the process actually take place?
• When are errors most likely to happen?

Determining the right time for certain actions, and comparing this with when they actually happen, can reveal potential mismatches that lead to problems.

Why?

The “Why” questions probe deeper into the causes of inefficiencies:

• Why are certain actions taken?
• Why are they performed in specific ways?
• Why do inefficiencies or errors arise?

These questions help in identifying the rationale behind existing practices, which may lead to discovering outdated or unnecessary steps.

How?

Finally, the “How” questions address the execution:

• How should tasks be performed?
• How are they currently being done?
• How can processes be optimised?

Focusing on execution helps you identify practical changes that can improve efficiency and eliminate errors.

5 Whys: Digging Deeper into Root Causes

The 5 Whys method complements 5W1H by providing a straightforward approach to uncover the root cause of a problem. It involves asking “Why?” five times (or more) until you reach the fundamental issue causing the problem. By repeatedly asking “Why?”, you peel back the layers of symptoms to expose the core issue.

This approach is widely used by companies like Toyota, where it became a rule to ask “Why?” five times as part of their problem-solving process. By focusing on cause and effect, the 5 Whys method helps to eliminate superficial solutions and tackle the real source of a problem.

Example of 5 Whys:

• Why did the machine stop?
  The fuse blew.
• Why did the fuse blow?
  The machine was overloaded.
• Why was the machine overloaded?
  The oil pump wasn’t circulating enough oil.
• Why wasn’t the oil pump circulating enough oil?
  The pump’s shaft was worn out.
• Why was the shaft worn out?
  It hadn’t been properly maintained.

By the fifth “Why,” we reach the root cause: inadequate maintenance, which leads to the deeper problem of machine failure.

Combining 5W1H and 5 Whys for Comprehensive Problem Solving

While 5W1H provides a broad framework to analyse all aspects of a problem, 5 Whys drills deeper into the underlying causes. Used together, these methods give a comprehensive understanding of what is wrong, why it is happening, and how to fix it.

For example, let’s look at a case where a product was accidentally dropped on the factory floor:

• Who dropped the product? (Who?)
• What caused the product to fall? (What?)
• Where did this happen? (Where?)
• When did the product fall? (When?)
• Why wasn’t the product secured? (Why?)
• How should it have been handled differently? (How?)

You can follow this with the 5 Whys:

• Why did the product fall?
  The box wasn’t sealed properly.
• Why wasn’t the box sealed properly?
  The worker didn’t have the right tools.
• Why didn’t the worker have the right tools?
  The tool was broken and not reported.
• Why wasn’t it reported?
  There was no system in place for reporting broken tools.
• Why was there no system in place?
  Lack of training on reporting procedures.

Here, combining both frameworks provides a clearer view of the problem and its solution.

People: The Common Denominator

One of the key takeaways from both 5W1H and 5 Whys is that most problems often come down to human factors. As Toyota often notes, 99.9% of problems are human-created, which emphasises the need for proper training, communication, and accountability in any organisation. People are both the creators and solvers of problems, making them the critical element in any improvement process.

Conclusion: Empowering Solutions through Inquiry

Both 5W1H and 5 Whys provide powerful frameworks for problem-solving by encouraging organisations to ask the right questions. These methods help uncover the true root causes of inefficiencies and mistakes, enabling organisations to implement targeted, sustainable solutions.

By fostering a culture of inquiry and continuous improvement, businesses can ensure long-term success and create an environment where problems are solved effectively and preventatively. So next time you face a challenge, start with 5W1H and follow it up with 5 Whys—you may be surprised at how deep the answers go.

Become a Lean Problem-Solving Expert: Enrol in Our Online Lean Black Belt Training

Ready to master problem-solving techniques like 5W1H and 5 Whys? Our online Lean Black Belt training is designed for professionals looking to enhance their skills in Lean methodology and process improvement. Learn at your own pace and take your business improvement expertise to the next level. Sign up today!