Fishbone or Ishikawa diagram

In the field of quality management, few tools are as valuable as the Ishikawa diagram, also known as the cause-and-effect diagram or fishbone diagram. This simple yet powerful tool serves as a flashlight, illuminating the root causes of problems that impair processes within an organization. By using the Ishikawa diagram, organizations can systematically investigate the causes of issues, moving beyond surface-level symptoms to uncover deeper, more critical process inefficiencies. Let’s take a closer look at how this tool works and why it’s so effective in Root Cause Analysis (RCA).

What is an Ishikawa Diagram?

The Ishikawa diagram, developed by Kaoru Ishikawa in the 1960s while he worked at Kawasaki Heavy Industries in Japan, is a visual tool used to identify potential causes of a problem. The diagram is structured like a fishbone, with the “head” representing the problem and the “bones” representing categories of potential causes.

The primary purpose of this diagram is to allow teams to brainstorm, analyze, and identify the root causes of issues systematically. It helps prevent teams from becoming fixated on surface-level problems or symptoms and enables them to dig deeper, focusing on the underlying process issues.

Using the Ishikawa Diagram to Uncover Root Causes

When using the Ishikawa diagram, it’s important to keep in mind that this tool is not about blaming individuals or finding fault. Instead, it focuses on identifying inefficiencies in processes. As emphasized in Lean methodology, the responsibility lies not with individuals, but with improving the process itself. With this in mind, the Ishikawa diagram serves as a guide to uncover the root causes that may be hiding within the organizational structure or workflow.

By organizing potential causes into categories, the diagram allows teams to methodically explore every angle of a problem, ensuring that all contributing factors are considered. In doing so, the team avoids focusing solely on the symptoms of an issue and, instead, identifies the root causes that will lead to sustainable improvement.

Structure of the Ishikawa Diagram

The Ishikawa diagram divides potential causes into six broad categories, commonly known as the 6 Ms. Each category helps dissect the different aspects of a process, allowing teams to explore a wide range of factors that may contribute to the issue.

The 6 Ms of the Ishikawa Diagram:

1. Manpower:
   • Are the employees involved in the process well-trained and experienced?
   • Is there clear communication among team members?
   • Are habits, behaviors, or work ethics contributing to the problem?
2. Machine (Tools, Equipment, and Software):
   • Are the machines or tools used in the process functioning correctly?
   • Could faulty equipment or software be contributing to the issue?
   • Are the machines safe and reliable?
3. Measurement:
   • How is quality being measured?
   • Are the standards for measurement consistent and reliable?
   • How often are measurements taken, and are they accurate?
4. Materials:
   • What materials are used in the process, and what is their quality?
   • Could poor-quality materials or improper use of materials be causing defects?
5. Environment (Milieu):
   • How do environmental factors such as temperature, humidity, noise, or lighting affect the process?
   • Could external factors be influencing the quality or efficiency of the process?
6. Method:
   • How are tasks being carried out, and is there a defined procedure?
   • Are logistics, communication, or administrative tasks being handled efficiently?
   • Is the process itself flawed or poorly designed?

Step-by-Step Guide to Conducting an Ishikawa Diagram Workshop

Creating an Ishikawa diagram can be an effective group exercise that promotes collaboration and creativity. Follow these steps to conduct an effective Root Cause Analysis (RCA) using the Ishikawa diagram:

1. Define the Problem:
   • Write the problem or effect you are analyzing in the “head” of the fish. This ensures that everyone understands what issue is being addressed.
2. Brainstorm Causes:
   • Have participants individually brainstorm as many potential causes as possible, using sticky notes or index cards to document their thoughts. Encourage participants to think creatively and avoid judgment.
3. Categorize the Causes:
   • Once all ideas have been gathered, organize them into the appropriate categories (the 6 Ms). Each participant will call out their suggestions, and the group will discuss where each cause fits within the diagram.
4. Add Sub-Causes:
   • Dig deeper into each category by adding sub-causes or secondary factors that could be contributing to the problem. These can be represented as smaller branches off the main “bones” of the diagram.
5. Analyze and Refine:
   • Review the entire diagram as a group. Ensure that the causes are categorized correctly, and consider how different causes may be related. Participants should offer suggestions for refining the diagram to make it as comprehensive as possible.
6. Prioritize the Causes:
   • Hold a group discussion or vote to determine the most likely root causes. Focus on the top 3-5 causes that are most likely to contribute to the issue. You can use the 5 Whys technique to dig deeper into each cause by asking “Why?” repeatedly until you reach the core issue.
7. Take Action:
   • Once the root causes have been identified, develop an action plan to address them. Prioritize solutions based on their impact and feasibility, and assign responsibilities for implementing changes.

Example of an Ishikawa Diagram in Action

Let’s say a manufacturing company is experiencing delays in product delivery. By using the Ishikawa diagram, the team identifies several potential causes, including:

• Manpower: Employees are unclear on production schedules.
• Machine: Frequent breakdowns of packaging machines slow down the process.
• Measurement: Inconsistent tracking of production time leads to inefficiencies.
• Materials: Incorrect materials are occasionally used, requiring rework.
• Environment: Noise in the production area affects communication among workers.
• Method: Production procedures are outdated and need updating.

By analyzing each category, the team can pinpoint the exact causes of the delays and take targeted action to improve the process.

Wrapping Up

The Ishikawa diagram is an invaluable tool in Root Cause Analysis for identifying the underlying causes of problems. Rather than focusing on who is at fault, the Ishikawa diagram helps teams explore how inefficiencies in processes contribute to issues. By systematically investigating each category and brainstorming potential causes, organizations can move beyond surface-level symptoms and address the root of the problem.

When embarking on your own quality management journey, the Ishikawa diagram can serve as your guide, helping you navigate the complexities of process improvement. Its simplicity belies its power, offering a clear path to operational excellence. Use it wisely, and watch as the layers of complexity peel away to reveal the true causes of your challenges.

Would you like to master Ishikawa and the Fishbone diagram? Our online Lean Six Sigma Green Belt course is perfect for you!