5 Whys: Digging Deeper into Root Causes

The 5 Whys method is a powerful and straightforward approach to uncover the root cause of any problem. It works by asking “Why?” five times (or more) to peel back the layers of symptoms and get to the fundamental issue causing the problem. Widely used by companies like Toyota, this technique became a key part of their problem-solving process, helping to eliminate superficial fixes and address the real source of an issue.

How the 5 Whys Method Works

The 5 Whys method focuses on the cause-and-effect relationship. By repeatedly asking “Why?”, you dig deeper into the problem to identify the underlying reason behind it. This approach prevents teams from stopping at the first sign of a problem and ensures that they get to the root cause, enabling them to implement more effective and lasting solutions.

Example of 5 Whys in Action

Let’s break down an example of the 5 Whys method in a manufacturing setting:

1. Why did the machine stop?
   The fuse blew.
2. Why did the fuse blow?
   The machine was overloaded.
3. Why was the machine overloaded?
   The oil pump wasn’t circulating enough oil.
4. Why wasn’t the oil pump circulating enough oil?
   The pump’s shaft was worn out.
5. Why was the shaft worn out?
   It hadn’t been properly maintained.

In this example, after five rounds of asking “Why?”, the root cause is identified as poor maintenance. The immediate problem was the machine stopping, but the true issue that caused the stoppage was a lack of proper upkeep.

The Role of 5 Whys in Root Cause Analysis

The 5 Whys method is often used alongside other root cause analysis techniques, such as 5W1H (Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How). While 5W1H provides a broad framework for analysing all aspects of a problem, 5 Whys digs deeper into the why behind the issue.

When used after tools like Ishikawa (fishbone diagrams) or brainstorming sessions, the 5 Whys method helps further clarify which potential causes are the actual root causes. It allows teams to go beyond surface-level conclusions and avoid implementing fixes that only address symptoms, not the underlying problem.

Why Does the 5 Whys Technique Work?

The simplicity of 5 Whys is what makes it so effective. Asking “Why?” multiple times forces you to think critically about the problem and focus on the cause-and-effect chain. This approach prevents teams from jumping to conclusions or settling for quick fixes.

In practice, it often takes around five rounds of asking “Why?” to reach the root cause, although it can sometimes take more or fewer questions. The key is to keep asking until you’re confident that you’ve uncovered the core issue.

Another Example of 5 Whys:

1. Why has the machine stopped?
   The fuse has blown.
2. Why did the fuse blow?
   The shaft was oiled insufficiently.
3. Why wasn’t there enough oil?
   The oil pump wasn’t working correctly.
4. Why didn’t the oil pump work properly?
   The shaft was worn out.
5. Why was the shaft worn out?
   The oil filter was clogged with metal splinters.

In this scenario, the root cause is identified as a clogged oil filter, which ultimately led to the machine malfunction. Understanding this root cause enables the organisation to implement better maintenance practices, ensuring that the issue doesn’t recur.

People as the Common Denominator

At Toyota, it’s often said that 99.9% of all problems are human-made. This highlights the fact that human error is a frequent cause of inefficiencies, mistakes, and process failures. By employing the 5 Whys method, organisations can pinpoint where human errors occur and take proactive steps to address them—whether through training, process improvement, or better communication.

Action Plan Example Using 5 Whys:

This table shows how 5 Whys can be used to create a clear action plan, solving not only the immediate problem (product falling) but also addressing the underlying issue (ordering errors).

Alternatives: 5 How

In some cases, teams may use an alternative approach called 5 How, which focuses on understanding how a problem occurred. While 5 Whys is used to drill down into why an issue exists, 5 How helps clarify the steps needed to solve the problem. Both methods can be valuable tools depending on the situation.

Conclusion: The Value of Asking “Why?”

The 5 Whys method is a simple yet powerful tool for identifying the root cause of problems. By repeatedly asking “Why?”, organisations can avoid the trap of implementing superficial fixes and instead focus on sustainable solutions that address the real issue. When combined with other techniques like 5W1H, the 5 Whys method provides a comprehensive framework for effective problem-solving and continuous improvement.

Asking “Why?” may seem like a basic step, but it’s often the key to unlocking deeper insights. Whether you’re in manufacturing, service industries, or any other field, incorporating the 5 Whys method into your problem-solving process can lead to more effective and lasting solutions.

Become a Lean Problem-Solving Expert: Enrol in Our Online Lean Black Belt Training

Ready to master problem-solving techniques like 5 Whys and 5W1H? Our online Lean Black Belt training is designed for professionals looking to enhance their skills in Lean methodology and process improvement. Learn at your own pace and take your business improvement expertise to the next level. Sign up today!